Before putting my list together this year, I spent some time looking back over the previous ten years in “Best of” posts. I was curious to see whether I’d still agree with my picks, how they’d hold up with time. There were a few oddballs in there (some intentional, some not). My early lists (which was pre-Spotify and the onset of unlimited access to new music) lacked some diversity. But for the vast majority of it I’d still endorse my picks.
As with other years, my favorite albums of 2017 have a bit of variety. Some rap, some indie-pop, electronic pop, folky stuff, singer-songwriter tunes. One area lacking this year was in the alt-country/Americana front. Most of my picks will probably be found on other “Best of” lists you see, but as usual I threw in a couple dark horse selections which may not resonate with others but they’re still my favorites and what I’d like to help make sure folks know about.
FAVORITE ALBUMS OF 2017
1. Run the Jewels 3, Run the Jewels – These guys are easy to take for granted or underestimate, but this album is the obvious, no-doubt-about-it, standout album of the year for me. This is the album I’ve turned to far more then anything else in the last 12 months. It’s the album that’s been my sounding board. It’s been my antidote to waves of Trumpism, kept me buoyed during darker times, helped me celebrate when I was looking for an instant party. This isn’t just great rap; it’s smart, powerful music with a social conscience.
2. Jacob the Horse, Jacob the Horse – This album could be the soundtrack to the best John Hughes movie we all somehow missed. From start to finish this album is my favorite kind of rock n roll. Whether by intent or simple dumb luck, these guys perfected the deceptively difficult balancing act of creating catchy, straight forward rock with undertones of sarcasm, self-depreciation, humor and irony. What might start off sounding like melodramatic 80’s era overkill is undercut by tongue-in-cheek wit, tipping us off to the contradictions that make music/life interesting.
3. DAMN., Kendrick Lamar – Another smart, powerful, rap album. There’s no denying the originality and creativity, but while other recent trend-setting rap artists ended up with music that lacked flow, I think Lamar’s album maintains a musical soul that keeps me engaged along with the complex content.
4. Process, Sampha – A meditative set of songs that sound like the 70’s soul music of Otis Redding, Sam Cooke, and Marvin Gaye channeled through the lens of today’s electronic R&B. The stand out track is Sampha’s heartbreakingly beautiful “(No One Knows Me) Like the Piano” but there’s plenty here to enjoy.
5. Turn Out the Lights, Julien Baker – Julien Baker is small, quiet, awkward, and unassuming but if you’re not careful, if you let yourself listen, she will break your heart. She did it with her debut album in 2015 and she’s come back even stronger here. It’s her specialty. I’ve warned you. (And if you see her perform live, you’re really in for it.)
6. Everybody Works, Jay Som – I hadn’t realized how much I enjoyed this album until I looked at my end-of-year track summary from Spotify and saw that I listened to it almost as much as anything else. That may demonstrate the subtle but beguiling nature of Duterte’s song writing. A mix of jangly pop and shoe gaze, the album sounds intimate but is full of masterfully catchy tracks which quickly build a sense of familiarity like the best pop music should.
7. Aromanticism, Moses Sumney – I came to this album late in the year and feel like I’ve only scratched the surface of what’s there but I knew it was special. In some ways, it makes me think of a classical rhapsody composition done with R&B styling. Beautiful, complex and genre defying music.
8. Preservation, Nadia Reid – I don’t think I can explain exactly why, but there are certain female voices that have an extra resonance for me. Folks like Neko Case and Jenny Lewis have been my prime examples but recently Nadia Reid has also joined that club. I don’t know much about the New Zealand artist but I stumbled onto her 2015 debut album and kept going back to it. Probably falling somewhere in the category of “indie-folk,” her new album Preservation added a bit more song writing complexity, a little more to the production value, while maintaining the succulent voice and rich layers of sound.
9. What Now, Sylvan Esso – A bit of an electro-pop chameleon, What Now can feel like a dance album, or dark and brooding, or sultry, or light-hearted and fun. I think all those layers are there and it just depends on what mood you project when you listen – which makes it a versatile album and I expect something that will hold up well over time.
Honorable Mention: Together at Last, Jeff Tweedy – If this album was a collection of new music, it would have made the top of my list. To be honest though, it’s really just a “best of Jeff Tweedy” collection done with new solo acoustic arrangements. But what a collection. Along with many others, I’ve argued for years that Jeff Tweedy is the best modern (and maybe beyond) song writer. These stripped down acoustic tracks highlight his lyrical craft and allow for a reflection on an amazing career that we’re all just lucky to benefit from.